Having analyzed Waiting for Godot, Endgame and Krapp’s Last Tape properly from a perspective in which I have considered tragededy as important as comedy, now we are arriving at the end of the paper. After summarizing which structure I have followed in my paper and which contents I have treated in order to make clar how my purpose have been achieved, I will discuss a little more extensively the aspect of the comedy or of the humour in Beckett’s theater and also focusing specifically in Godot, Krapp’s and Endgame.
First of all, I have talked about Samuel Beckett in a existentialist background. Effectively, his period of artistic development as an author took place in a literary and philosophical context where the Existentialism was spreading its ideas about human and the world, more concretely about the existence, as the doctrine’s name indicates. The ideas basically were concerned about the absurdity of life and how people confront this spiritual and psychological problem. This philosphy more inclined to a post-modern world than to a modern thought, did not bet anymore for rationality and progress, since a terrible war recently had demonstrated the madness of humanity. We can locate Samuel Beckett in this worldview, but not completely. Actually, Beckett theater deals with the deep human’s essence: an irrational and fragile creature who intensely fears freedom and uncertainty. The main difference between Beckett’s theater and other Existentialist playwrights such as Jean-Paul Sartre is that Beckett’s plays are as irrational in content and in form as life itself. Until he came, absurdist or existentialist plays portrayed the senselessness of the world maintaining the rational and conventional forms.
After introducing this philosophical background, I have argued that as Beckett’s theater is in a way existentialist since it deals with the absurdity of life, therefore it has been labelled as ‘Theater of the Absurd’. But we have to be careful with this term because it is more complex than that. Moreover, for the fact that his plays are ‘absurd’, many critics (as the Spanish Ángel Fernández-Santos or the English John Flecther) believe that it does not make sense trying to interpret them as symbolist pieces of theater. Here we have an example of what Fletcher thinks (I already put one of Fernández-Santos in the introduction):
[In Waiting for Godot many interpreations have tried to establish a truth: Chrisian, Marxist, Atheist… But it is absurd] »in fact Beckett’s play have been more aptly termed ‘drama of the non-specific’ »(Alec Reid). [It is senseless to] «look for a ‘specific’ meaning». Beckett’s art avoid definition because he believed passionately that ‘art has nothing to do with clarity, does not dabble in the clear and does not make clear’. The writer is no ‘magus’ possessing privileged insight or knowledge not revealed to other mortals; all he or she can do is distil in words, however imperfect, a vision or experience of the misery and desperateness of life. That, for Beckett, was ‘poetry’ broadly defined, and it was for him the only thing that ultimately had any value.» (48)
It is exactly what Fernández-Santos opines, and from my point of view thy are in a subtle way contradicting themselves with regard Beckett’s theater. If we are admiring Beckett’s dramatic essence because it depicts the absurdity of life, why are we critizicing those critics or ordinary people that have tried to interpret his plays as hiding symbols to be decoded? This academic or intellectual impulse is natural. I did so myself in the first paper, but I haven’t considered my interpretative conclusions are totally correct and absolute, but just what they are: subjective interpretations. I think Santos and Flecther are right in the sense of what Beckettian plays are about ‘distil in words a vision or experience of the misery and desperateness of life’, but it does not entail necessarily to that moralistic thought of not seeing Beckett’s plays as symbolists. What really cares in my opinion is the intensity and enthusiasm of analyzing something, not the ‘objective truth’.
Jumping to another theme, to the concept of ‘absurd’ is very linked that of the humour if we observe what produces us laughing in the everyday: when a person acts in an unexpected way (comically or innocently) enfront a tense situation. This translated in terms of Beckett theater refers to his characters seeming children, clowns or insensitive people giggling, laughing or guffawing when they have listened to a cruel story about a poor man needing desperately a job to feed his children (Endgame). Then one can think that Beckett is cruel and malevolent, but is not as simple as that. If he only had represented scenes like that (laughing at the miseries of life) then this person opining about his immorality maybe would be right. But the fact is that he plays with many ‘comic tones’, as Fintan O’Toole has theorized, and I have selected some as I consider they could be of the reader interest:
Within the parameters of his exploitation of the humour of theatre itself and the dark comedy of a bleak and depressed society, Beckett uses a dazzling range of comic tones.
–Gallows humour (literally so in the pathetic attempts of Didi and Gogo to hang themselves).
–Slapstick (that multitude in transports of joy-Endgame)
-Elements of farce (the elaborate business with boots, carrots, hairbrushes, ladders, telescopes and all the inanimate objects that cause so much trouble throughout the plays).
-Comic irony (the blind Hamm in Endgame lavishing his affection on a three-legged toy dog). -Mock-heroic posturing (Didi and Gogo’s absurdly grave discourse on radishes).
-Mock-epic satire (the way, for example, that Endgame makes a mockery of Hamlet).
-Sheer [pure or simple] absurdity (Krapp’s banana).
In my opinion it could be no better explained with this example, although obsviously one could extract so many more ‘comic tones’ as one wants, because imagination and sensitiveness are limitless. As we can see, Beckett mocks in general all related to seriousness or formality: classic works of literature, academicity, ancient heros, traditionality and sadness. And because he teases the tragic aspects of life it does not mean that he thinks we have to be positive, always smiling, to make of the world a better place. Beckett, at the same time that he accepts pain, he denies tragedy. And from this peculiar and exquisite contradiction are based his artistic productions. To finalize with this point of the humour, I will present another example of how Beckett plays with humour in his theater: through the metatheater. I previously explained in the introduction this theme, saying that the character’s dialogues makes reference to the general concept of theater itself. Thus they can point to the idea of characters, to the idea of author, or even to the role of actors. But also to the audience, for instance, when Clov in Endgame looks directly towards the audience with his telescope:
Clov: “I see . . . a multitude . . . in transports . . . of joy.” (Pause) That’s what I call a magnifier.
(He lowers his telescope, turns toward Hamm.) Well? Don’t we laugh?
As Harbin Leigh clarifies, “the audience does not remain outside the line of fire of Clov’s sarcasm, and his use of “we” here implicitly includes everyone in the theater. (3) And he also concludes from this that “Beckett’s comedy leads to a subtle, yet complex self-reflexive theater.” (2)
With this more detailed explanation of the humour’s paper in Beckett’s plays I hope the reader have understood what is my purpose with this essay. The theater of Samuel Beckett «represent a clear and intelligible, if admittedly complex, metaphor about the nature of existence» (Fletcher 49). And the ‘nature of our existence’ is with no doubt an unstable and hazardous combination of happy-comical moments with painful-tragic experiences.