Introduction

Is the theater of Samuel Beckett absurd? I am convinced that the majority of people would answer yes. And it is not surprising taking into account this is the way critics have labelled it through time: the Theater of the Absurd. This term was coined in 1960 by the critic Martin Esslin in his essay «Theater of the Absurd» inspired by the previous work of Albert Camus «The Myth of Sisyphus» (1942). Martin Esslin’s essay focused on the most representative authors of the absurd, which included Samuel Beckett, Eugène Ionesco, Arthur Adamov and Jean Genet. The philosophy of this essay portrays the essence of their experimental plays, so ground-breaking for the time. They were considered ‘absurd’ because, in very general terms, they expressed the irrationality of the world: human existence has no purpose and therefore the communication turns illogical. Trying to rationalise the world does not make any sense anymore, as everything that happens is by random and we don’t have the capacity of control it. No gods, no human: life manipulates us mercilessly.

However, we have to be careful with the term ‘absurd’. On the one hand, ‘absurd’ can be correct if it refers to the painful and anguish life we have to live one we are born, that is, to what authors as Samuel Beckett represent in the plays. On the other hand, it can’t be related to the intention of the author and to everything that happens in the stage during the representation. Samuel Beckett, although he can have a different perspective of life, of understanding human existence in comparison to modernist authors, he also has concerns, thoughts, feelings and opinions. He has a strenght inside him that, along with his inquisitiveness or artistic aspirations, need to be turned into a creation (the fiction play) and communicated or transmitted to an audience. Thus, in this sense, as there is a purpose or an end, absurdity here is not the precise term. The second point is that just because it is labelled as ‘absurd’ it does not mean that all actions and dialogues of a play are completely illogical and contingent. In fact, there is also a purpose showing irrationally the irrationality. And in these senseless actions we see ourselves reflected.

The concept of the ‘absurd’ is also very linked to the existentialist philosophy. Both deal with human existence, as the first is a kind of definition or calification, and the second is the study of it. The work of Samuel Beckett have been often contemplated as a product of this theory. It could be right in the sense that existentialists and Beckett share this predispositon of going into the roots of human feelings and behaviour and how they confront their own world. The Heideggerian concept of being-there in the world and the anguish it entails are some philosophic ideas the both Beckett and existentialist thinkers deal with. Existentialist playwrighters and philosophers as Sartre, Marcel and Camus have exposed these themes in their plays in a rational way, that is, the style, actions, dialogues and the structure of the play in general does not abandon at all the rational forms. Instead, Samuel Beckett is able to represent these irrational and metaphysical issues studied by existentialist in a irrational form. In fact, «nothing distinct from the silence can express the silence», and «only the emptiness is able to transmit what the emptiness is about»1 (Fernández-Santos, 19).

Consequently, Beckett’s theater is not only derived from Existentialism, but also denies it in a way. We can think about it as «an attempt to express to what extent is ridiculous the effort of the existentialist philosophy to decipher the indecipherable», as the critic Ángel Fernández-Santos points out in his essay «The Sceptic Theater of Samuel Beckett»2 (16). As the drama of Beckett is a complete break up with the rational processes and the speculative thinking, it seems a little contradictory trying to find an absolute truth in his plays. Nevertheless, many critics have interpreted them as if they hide dark and very abstract elements which need to be unmasked and therefore rationalised. Who represents Godot in the real life? Is God? And what about Pozzo and Lucky? Are they materializing the body of the owner and the slave? Is Hamm symbolizing Joyce and Clov Beckett? Numerous questions of this kind has received Samuel Beckett after his theater representations, but no explicit statements have been replied: «(…)if by Godot I had meant God I would [have] said God, and not Godot» (Beckett). The critic Fernández-Santos defends that this interpretative effort «has to be abandoned completely» when we face Beckett’s theater, as we would be»destroy[ing] the true meaning of his theater work»3 (21).

It may be true that Beckett’s intentions are not about expressing a veracity in his dramatic creations; he leaves everything open to the audience and it is the key for this peculiar perplexity that his artistic work cause on us. But it does not imply that critics have to abstain themselves from establishing interpretative or symbolist theories. In fact, this common behaviour among critics does not destroy Samuel Beckett’s essence, but affirm or support it. Precisely, these efforts confirm Beckett’s concerns about human weakness: we need to take refuge in something to feel more comfortable and safe. Watching one of his plays with an interpretative intention would give us later the impression that we have understood the ‘abstract meaning’ of the play. Consequently, elaborating distinct theories about one certain topic is a natural human impulse, but it is important not to consider them as perfectly settled. In the play Endgame there is a dialogue that clearly defines this aspect. The characters (Hamm and Clov) talk about what would do a ‘rational being’ (the symbolist) when watching them (while they are acting in the play):

Hamm: I wonder. Imagine if a rational being came back to earth, wouldn’t he be liable to get ideas into his head if he observed us long enough (Voice of rational being) Ah, good, now I see what it is, yes, now I understand what they’re at! (…) To think perhaps it won’t all have been for nothing! (27)

And another that subtly mocks the interpretative effort again:

Hamm: We’re not beginning to… to… mean something?

Clov: Mean something! You and I, mean something! Ah that’s a good one! (27)

Thus Hamm and Clov could mean anything or everything one is inclined to think. What Beckett refers to is that the characters are just a mean for express general human concerns (or the idea of the man and the world). As Maurice Nadeau states, the language of Beckett’s theater is that «of our own interior voice hitherto unknown and suddenly found».

Since now I have briefly introduced some angles of view to understand better Beckett’s theater, contrasting the term ‘absurd’ with ‘existentialist’ and also finding the elements in common. Secondly I have argued to what extent is contradictory trying to find symbolisms in an absurd play, but defending that although it is incongruous it does not mean we don’t have to do it. My purpose with this is to go into detail about the essence of his artistic personality and consequently of his literary products, so then understanding the topic of my paper can result easier and more interesting. Finally I am going to focus on Beckett’s theater more specifically, and soon I will develop my central idea or topic (the tragic and comic aspects in three of his plays) as well as my method in what could be the main body of the essay.

The playwright John Spurling once said: «Samuel Beckett was waiting for the theatre as the theatre was waiting for Samuel Beckett». As I explained in my first paper, particularly in the part 02 (LINK!), he «abandoned the notions of rationality and logic of the so well constructed modern plays», getting to «disrupt the dramatic conventions». John Fletcher remarks that Samuel Beckett «has found the means of setting out the metaphysical doubts that torment us» (16-17). And not only have puzzled us in terms of the content, but also of the form. The author is a great «manipulator of, exploiter of, and performer [with all the] possibilities of language» (Fletcher, 19). In his plays are often present «the use of banal, everyday conversations mixed with literary language, the slang, puns, and modified clichés, as well as the careful creation of rhythms and use of repetitions», which contribute to a «new and powerful dramatic expressiveness». (Fletcher, 19, quoting from French Review). Another characteristc is Beckett’s plays are the metatheatrical aspects introduced in a subtle manner. We can see this in some of the dialogues of Endgame:

  1. – I’ll soon have finished with this story. Unless I bring in other characters. But where would I find them? Where would I look for them? (37)

  2. – There are days like that, one isn’t inspired. Nothing you can do about it, just wait for it to come. No forcing, no forcing, it’s fatal.

  3. – […] Me to play. We’re getting on. (44)

  4. – What is there to keep me here?

    – The dialogue. (39)

The first and second dialogue allude to the role of writer, who could be Samuel Beckett. The third refers to the role of actors who represent Hamm and Clov, and finally the fourth suggests the situation of the characters, which are product of the creation of Samuel Beckett. These metaphysical scenes demonstrates us how important is the theater, the artistic conception of a fiction situation where the characters are just these characters, and their actions are just their actions, etc. One could see them as being more than just that, as symbolic elements, but Beckett will not give you the answer as there is none.

Having illustrated briefly the theater of Beckett within a theatrical and philosophical background, now I am going to expose what is my intention with this paper. In my first paper I talked about Waiting for Godot not only from an analytical point of view, but also from a psychological and biographical perspective from the personality and life of its author Samuel Beckett. I focused more on the tragic aspects of the play, but in the conclusion I discussed the humorous aspects which so much characterizes Beckett’s plays and are frequently forgotten by the critics when studying Beckett. As the critic John Fletcher defines, «Beckett, despite his reputation as a gloomy pessimist, certainly did not lack a sense of humour» (Fletcher, 13-14). It is clear that the playwright portrays how absurd and irrational is the world, and the anxiety and emptiness this entails sometimes, but we must not forget HOW he does it: mocking the pain itself with comic elements that the silly and illogical situations produce. ‘Humour’ and ‘absurd’ are two words that should be always together, as the absurdity is the humour’s basis. Only Beckett knows how to create this sublime contradiction presenting us a negative or pessimistic perspective and at the same time another more comical and tender. A cold and bleak speech pronounced in a rational tone and voice (typical of a depressed intellectual) can be suddenly collapsed by a cynical guffaw, or interrupted by a childish action or expression. This idea can’t be more plainly expressed in the subtitle of the play Waiting for Godot: a tragicomedy in two acts. What I want to achieve with this is to make that the reader realize how important is the humour in Beckett’s plays, but from a point of view in which it contrasts with the dramatic aspects. Drama and humour, comedy and tragedy, as I said before, complement each other and constitute the essence of Beckett’s theater.

In this paper I will bring into focus this topic, developing it from the analysis of three plays: Waiting for Godot, Endgame and Krapp’s Last Tape. These plays were written in the late 1950’s, when Samuel Beckett was in a period of intense experimentation. The Second World War caused him great pain, coming to mean a traumatic experience. But it, paradoxically, also inspired and motivated him incredibly, as we will check later in the analysis of the three plays.

«After a rational attempt to order the outside world, his fiction should deal with the ‘darkness’ of the inner self» (Pattie 29)

With regard to my method, first I will introduce in a general way on what are based the tragedy and the comedy and how Beckett approaches them in his plays with a different perspective. Beckett’s concept of tragedy is not that of the Ancients, where the freedom of a brave hero is depends on the power of a deity or on any external circumstance. This classic hero will have to overcome obstacles to get it, and while doing that, his life is full of action, motivation and expectations. Whilst this hero accepts the pain but looks for a solution, the Beckettian anti-heros also accept the pain but deny the tragedy. By denying the tragedy I mean that they turn it into comedy: they tease the suffering of living.

In this part of the tragedy and comedy I will deal for the first time with some key concepts: physical and psychological decay and death. These three issues considered as tragic are present in the three plays I will analyze, but in each one with different nuances. Then I will dip into the individual analysis of each play: Waiting for Godot, Endgame and Krapp’s Last Tape, exposing the tragic and comic aspects and how they are interrelated, that is, contrasted or mixed.

_______________________________________________________________

1″Nada distinto del silencio puede expresar al silencio. Sólo el vacío tiene la voz capaz de transmitir en qué consiste el vacío»

2″Como un intento de expresar hasta qué punto es descabellado el esfuerzo de la filosofía existencialista por descifrar lo indescifrable»

3″cualquier hábito mental de esta especie debe ser abandonado por completo al enfrentarnos con un teatro como el de Beckett […] es una forma de destruir el verdadero sentido de su materia teatral»

Articulo publicado en Sin categoría. Guarda el enlace permanente.

Deja una respuesta

Tu dirección de correo electrónico no será publicada. Los campos obligatorios están marcados con *